Chronic Suppurative Otitis Media: A Comprehensive Review of Epidemiology, Pathogenesis, Microbiology, and Complications (2024)

Monitoring Editor: Alexander Muacevic and John R Adler

Abstract

Keywords: tympanoplasty, cholesteatoma, biofilm infections, aom, csom

Introduction and background

Chronic suppurative otitis media (CSOM) is one of the most common infectious diseases encountered in the practice of otolaryngology, affecting children globally, regardless of geographical or socioeconomic status. The incidence of CSOM is estimated at more than 20 million people worldwide. Research conducted in industrialized nations reveals that roughly 80% of preschoolers might have gone through at least a single episode of acute otitis media (AOM) before they turn three, and nearly 40% will experience six or more recurrences by the time they reach the age of seven. Comparable to other communicable ailments, AOM's impact varies significantly among different countries based on factors such as suppurative complications prevalence like mastoiditis, meningitis incidence rate, and sequelae development likelihood associated with CSOM resulting in hearing loss [1-3]. CSOM is a condition where there is a prolonged inflammation of the mucosa in the middle ear and mastoid space. It persists for more than two months, which causes a hole to form in the eardrum and results in ongoing discharge from the ear canal. This persistent ailment can cause profound health implications, such as complications within the intracranial area and significant morbidity among those affected. These adverse outcomes make CSOM a major public health issue that requires immediate attention to curb its prevalence worldwide [4-7]. The occurrence of this condition exhibits considerable variation across different nations; however, it is particularly prevalent in countries with low- and middle-income levels. By definition, chronic suppurative otitis media is a chronic infectious disease associated with inflammation of the middle ear and mastoid mucosa, which can lead to perforation or formation of a tympanostomy tube and discharge (otorrhea) [8,9]. There is no common consensus regarding symptom duration, although some classifications define it as "otorrhea through a perforated tympanic membrane lasting for at least two weeks," whereas others describe 'chronic' symptoms persisting beyond six weeks [10-13].

The definition of CSOM varies depending on the duration and severity of symptoms, but it is generally acknowledged that CSOM follows unsuccessfully or partially treated acute otitis media [14,15]. However, there is no clear distinction between otorrhea as a sign of AOM and CSOM. It should be noted that tympanostomy tube otorrhea, which results from complications with placing ear tubes, should not be confused with CSOM. Chronic otitis media with effusion (OME) without active infection or perforation in the eardrum must also be differentiated from CSOM and chronic perforations without middle-ear infections. When dealing with cases involving cholesteatoma deposition around the inflamed tissues inside the ears, it is referred to as CSOM with cholesteatoma. However, CSOM primarily affects children in the first five years of life, particularly in developing countries and among populations with craniofacial anomalies [16].

CSOM has two distinct types: the first is the benign or tubotympanic type, which primarily affects the inferior anterior region of the middle ear cleft and results in permanent central perforation. Despite this symptom, individuals with this type of CSOM are not prone to severe complications. On the other hand, the second classification is known as the malignant or atticoantral type-also called the "danger" type since it involves both the attic and posterosuperior regions of the middle ear-posing severe health risks for those affected by it [17]. The misuse and excessive use of antibiotics in recent times have led to changes in important bacterial strains as well as their responses to antibiotics. As a result, addressing this situation has become more complex. There have been reports on the changing prevalence and antibiogram (antibiotic sensitivity patterns) of micro-organisms causing chronic otitis media over time and across different regions. This is likely due to the indiscriminate usage of antibiotics. Therefore, regularly updating information on the prevalence and antibiogram of these microorganisms for chronic otitis media would aid in patient treatment. Currently, early identification through microbiological diagnosis ensures timely and effective treatment while also helping prevent complications.

Review

Risk factors

Several risk factors can contribute to the development of CSOM. It is more commonly observed in children, especially those in lower socioeconomic groups. The immature immune system and higher susceptibility to infections in children increase their risk. Other risk factors include frequent or untreated acute otitis media, inappropriate treatment for ear infections, poor hygiene, and environmental factors such as living in an unclean or overcrowded environment, low socioeconomic status, limited access to healthcare facilities, inadequate healthcare resources, genetic predisposition, malnutrition, and structural abnormalities like cleft palate [18]. Other unique factors that increase the likelihood of CSOM include frequent AOM and parents who have had CSOM in the past [3]. Further, allergies can be considered another risk factor, given that certain research studies have indicated the existence of allergens causing hindrance to both the Eustachian tube and nasal passages [19].

Methodology

Literature Search

To gather extensive information on the topic, we performed a thorough literature search with 47 PDF-accessible articles after removing the duplicates published after 2015 (Appendix, Table ​Table1).1). Additional articles were referred to, which were cited by these articles. We utilized various databases such as PubMed, Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar. Our search included specific keywords relevant to our study, including "chronic suppurative otitis media", "CSOM", "microbiology", "treatment", "prevalence", and "burden of disease". We also manually searched the reference lists of relevant articles to identify additional studies.

Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria

Incorporated in our research were studies that explored the various aspects of CSOM, such as microbiology, epidemiology, diagnosis, treatment, and prevention. However, we opted to exclude non-English studies and those that did not undergo the peer-review process.

Data Extraction and Synthesis

In order to conduct our analysis, we obtained information from each study that was included in the research. To evaluate this collected information effectively, we employed a narrative approach, which allowed us to provide an overview while highlighting important and current details.

Data Analysis

In our analysis, we employed a qualitative method to examine the data. We focused on identifying recurring themes and patterns that emerged from the studies included in our research. Furthermore, we utilized descriptive statistics as a means of succinctly summarizing the findings obtained.

Epidemiology

CSOM is frequent, especially prevalent in underprivileged communities and developing nations. Its predominance varies between 1 and 46% according to the demographic region and population [20].Although CSOM affects adults too, it primarily strikes children, mainly from two- to five-year-olds. It has also been documented among elders more frequently [21]. A shared characteristic of these congenital abnormalities pertains to insufficient Eustachian tube functionality, a condition that elevates the vulnerability of affected children towards middle-ear ailments [22]. Risk determinants primarily related to CSOM consist of (A) frequent occurrences of acute otitis media, (B) infections within the upper respiratory tracts, (C) any injury affecting the tympanic membrane, and (D) inadequate nutrition and poor living arrangements.

Globally, the illness impacts many individuals, ranging from 65 to 330 million. The majority who are affected reside in less developed nations. It has been approximated that there is an annual incidence of 31 million new cases of CSOM, out of which approximately one-fifth account for children below five years old [23].

Mechanisms/Pathophysiology

Despite the substantial disease burden, OM cases in developed countries are typically uncomplicated and self-limiting, with little incidence of persistent hearing impairment or developmental delay [24]. However, high-risk populations residing in developing and well-developed regions often experience significant lifelong hearing loss due to complex exposure to multiple genetic, environmental, and social risk factors. The progression of OM pathology is an intricate amalgamation that begins with early colonization by bacteria within the nasopharynx, followed by premature onset acute otitis media (AOM). Over time, this leads to acute inflammation cycles within the middle ear due to ongoing exposure to infective agents such as bacterial persistence through biofilm formation; viral infection ultimately results in severe chronic conditions involving the ears (Figure ​(Figure1)1) [25].

Eustachian Tube Anatomy

A functional Eustachian tube plays a vital role in safeguarding the middle ear by preventing the invasion of bacterial otopathogens and respiratory viruses, facilitating the drainage of secretions from this area, and ensuring pressure equalization. In infants, immature Eustachian tube anatomy significantly contributes to susceptibility to infections in the middle ear. The main line of defense against entry and colonization by otopathogens is located within the epithelium lining this structure, consisting primarily of ciliated respiratory epithelial cells that synthesize antimicrobial proteins (e.g., lysozyme). Additionally, goblet cells interspersed among these produce both serous and mucoid mucus. The action controls the proper direction through which mucociliary flow occurs, moving from the nasopharynx toward the middle ear, while antimicrobial protein secretion protects against inflammatory reactions caused by bacteria residing there [26].

In neonates and young children less than one year of age, the Eustachian tube is characterized by a shorter length, a wider diameter, and a greater horizontal inclination. This structure permits easier transmission of pathogens to the middle ear, leading to a higher susceptibility to otitis media. Placing infants in a supine position also aggravates their vulnerability to infections. As kids grow older, a shift downward in skull base elevation results in a gradual increase at an angle from 10° (at birth) up to about 45° (in adults), while concomitantly increasing in length from approximately 13 mm at birth until it reaches ∼35 mm when fully grown-up. Adjustments occurring due to these alterations, along with maturation in immune function, can contribute towards a decreased risk profile about OM even among those classified as high-risk candidates for otitis media infection [27].

Bacterial Infections and Biofilms

The pathogenesis of CSOM involves a fusion of various factors that contribute to the continued existence of middle ear infections and inflammation. The onset of this condition generally starts with acute otitis media, characterized by an infection in the intermediate ear. Inadequate treatment or inherent risk elements may result in the development of CSOM, an advanced stage of AOM. Impaired Eustachian tube function plays a significant role in leading to CSOM. When a rupture in the tympanic membrane occurs spontaneously or due to the insertion of tubes into the eardrum, it leads to the loss of the middle ear's "gas cushion." This results in backflow or reflux of secretions from the nasopharynx through the Eustachian tube [28].

As a consequence, contamination with respiratory pathogens takes place. Pressure equilibrium between the middle ears and the outer atmosphere can lead to insufficient drainage and ventilation, causing bacteria or fungus overgrowth. Reduced ciliary functions of the middle ear and Eustachian tubes; persistence or frequent recurrence is another significant factor leading to chronic irritation among individuals with CSOM; it could be due to incomplete eradication methods against bacterial pathogens or restrained immune response mechanisms inadequately combating infections. Biofilms in CSOM, comprising structured bacterial communities enclosed within a protective matrix, can be attributed to the persistence of the infection [29,30]. The presence of biofilms enhances antibiotic resistance and the immune evasion ability of bacteria, thereby hindering effective treatment measures [31].

Microbiology

The microbiology of CSOM entails the existence of diverse microorganisms, occasionally including fungi, within the middle ear. Among these bacteria, Pseudomonas aeruginosa prevails and is deemed clinically consequential due to its adeptness in developing biofilms and capacity for antibiotic resistance. Alongside it, Staphylococcus aureus usually cohabits with a similar inflammatory impact, as this bacterium can generate harmful toxins that trigger tissue damage. Moreover, Streptococcus pneumoniae is another common cause of acute otitis media that may also lead to CSOM cases.

Other bacteria include Haemophilus influenzae, Moraxella catarrhalis, Proteus spp., and anaerobic microorganisms such as Peptostreptococcus spp. and Prevotella spp. Furthermore, in areas with specific geographic conditions or among individuals who have a weakened immune system, fungal infections like Aspergillus spp. and Candida spp. can also contribute to the condition's progression. To find out the anaerobic etiological agent, the otolaryngologist needs to remember the probability that anaerobic organisms are also causative agents. Based on the gram staining picture, the microbiologist can report the probable causative agent.Depending on factors like geographical location, personal immunity status, history of antibiotic use, and other host elements involved, CSOM microbiology varies greatly. Henceforth, appropriately identifying pathogens through microbiological testing is crucial for formulating effective treatment strategies to manage them effectively.

Immunology and Genetics

The body's immune system and genetic makeup are critical in managing CSOM. Immunoglobulins IgG, IgA, and secretory IgA are most effective in guarding against mucosal infections like CSOM. Locally synthesized by plasma cells within the middle-ear cavity mucosa, SIgA helps prevent bacterial attachment to and colonization of this area. However, children with CSOM may have deficient levels of SIgA [32]. The IgG-class immunoglobulin concentration primarily acts to facilitate phagocytosis either directly or indirectly via complement activation, which depends on the age factor. Children experiencing recurring upper respiratory tract illnesses portray reduced levels of specific subclasses, such as mostly low-targeting antibody activity from subclass-IgG2 in 10-20% of cases [33,34]. For antibodies to be action-ready for infection prevention, coating on bacteria walls stands prerequisite. While intense SIgA and IgG coatings prevail commonly during a case involving bacterial causation other than Pseudomonas aeruginosa responsible, there has been no sighted coverage when that particular pathogen causes an infection, indicating its resistance towards these two responses.

Despite conflicting data regarding inadequate antibody responses to otopathogens in children at risk of developing OM, there is increasing clarity on the possible involvement of cell-mediated impairment. The impact of genetics on these findings remains uncertain, and it is plausible that interactions between pathogens, hosts, and surroundings could play a part. Additional investigation is required for a comprehensive comprehension of how genetic factors contribute to the development of OM.

Complications and sequelae

CSOM can result in various complications, including conductive or sensorineural hearing loss, extracranial complications (e.g., facial paralysis, subperiosteal abscess, mastoiditis), and intracranial complications (e.g., meningitis, cerebral abscess). Prompt diagnosis and management are crucial to prevent long-term consequences, particularly in pediatric patients. Meningitis and brain abscesses are the primary causes of death resulting from OM and CSOM. WHO estimates show that a significant number, ranging from 65 million to 330 million individuals, display symptoms associated with CSOM [23], out of which half suffer from hearing impairment. In developed nations, after hypertension and arthropathy, hearing loss (including conductive and sensorineural) is considered the third chronic ailment prevailing among older adults affecting their physical and mental well-being in considerable ways. Conversely, data on less industrialized countries' adult populations remains sparse regarding such conditions. Therefore, a thorough understanding of AOM's incidence rate across demographics must be established to reduce health issues alongside social-economic adversity by intervening at the right time (Figure ​(Figure22).

Prognosis

In general, CSOM’s outlook is favorable, provided it receives proper treatment and no complications are involved. A few cases may be refractory, which entails a more comprehensive assessment and management. It is vital to identify and treat the bacterial origin of acute otitis media, as this can lead to CSOM in most instances. The use of the Pneumococcus vaccine has resulted in a positive reduction in the incidence of acute otitis media, thereby decreasing the occurrence rate of patients presenting with CSOM.

Prevention

Due to the complex nature of OM, there are several preventive measures that can be employed. These measures primarily center around minimizing modifiable factors that contribute to risk, such as infectious agents and environmental hazards.

Vaccines directed against bacterial otopathogens: The vaccines aim to reduce or eliminate nasopharyngeal colonization by S. pneumoniae and H. influenzae. The vaccine has been added to the primary series of universal vaccination schedules with a 20% reduction in the CSOM by using ventilation tubes.

Deterrence and patient education

Parents need to be informed and guided about the significance of consistent visits for their child's overall health check-ups, as well as being encouraged to promptly seek medical attention when their children report ear pain or discomfort. Additionally, it is crucial to take into account any concerns raised by teachers regarding potential hearing loss in a child. Addressing and managing CSOM in a timely manner is critical in reducing the risk of long-term complications that may impact the child's well-being.

Enhancing Healthcare Team Outcomes

CSOM is a medical condition characterized by a persistent infection in the middle ear that damages the eardrum. This disease usually manifests during early childhood, typically around two years old, and may follow an episode of acute otitis media. It is vital to isolate the causative agent upon suspicion of this ailment promptly. If left unchecked, CSOM can result in severe complications such as polyps, sclerosis, or hardening of tissues within the ear cavity walls; tympanosclerosis or thickening and scarring on hearing-related components within our ears causing conductive hearing loss; labyrinthitis, which triggers inflammation affecting areas close to inner-ear nerves leading to balance issues with dizziness spinning sensations and nausea over time these symptoms lead up cognitive impedances like disorientation seizures, etc.; epidural abscesses culminating in excruciating headaches swelling nervousness convulsion depression (psychiatric disorders), subdural abscesses making it difficult for one's coordination, tongue movement awareness, memory processing, communication problem solving skills, mental flexibility, adaptation capability, along with development requiring surgery intervention if necessary, alongside brain abscesses compromising one's ability, even more debilitating auditory effects are so familiar that children are unable to attend school regularly because of decreased academic performance impacting scholastic ability.

Limitations

There are a number of limitations in our review that need to be acknowledged. Firstly, it is important to note that non-English studies were excluded from the analysis, which may lead to some bias and restrict the generalizability of our findings. Additionally, we should consider potential publication bias as another limitation since there is always a possibility that studies with significant results are more likely to be published compared to those with null or non-significant findings. Lastly, it's worth mentioning that the quality of the included studies varied across different sources, which could have an impact on the overall validity and reliability of our conclusions.

Conclusions

CSOM remains a significant childhood chronic infectious disease with global implications. A child with persistent upper respiratory tract infection with pain in the ear has the highest chance of developing otitis media. If failed to treat timely can lead to severe complications. Understanding its epidemiology, pathogenesis, microbiology, and associated complications is essential for effectively managing and preventing long-term sequelae. The complications of CSOM do affect the cognitive and educational development of the child as well as long-term effects on the child's communication. Further research is needed to enhance our knowledge of CSOM and develop targeted interventions.

Appendices

Notes

The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

References